'Mind Control' Science Takes a Step Closer to Reality
by Pam Belluck,
Memories and the feelings associated with them are not set in stone. You may have happy memories about your family's annual ski vacation, but if you see a tragic accident on the slopes, those feelings may change. You might even be afraid to ski that mountain again.
Now, using a technique in which light is used to switch neurons on and off, neuroscientists at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology appear to have unlocked some secrets about how the brain attaches emotions to memories and how those emotions can be adjusted.
Their research, published Wednesday in the journal Nature, was conducted on mice, not humans, so the findings cannot immediately be translated to the treatment of patients. But experts said the experiments may eventually lead to more effective therapies for people with psychological problems such as depression, anxiety or post-traumatic stress disorder.
Imagine you can go in and find a particular traumatic memory and turn it off or change it somehow, said David Moorman, an assistant professor of psychological and brain sciences at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, who was not involved in the research. That's still science fiction, but with this we're getting a lot closer to it.
The M.I.T. scientists labeled neurons in the brains of mice with a light-sensitive protein and used pulses of light to switch the cells on and off, a technique called optogenetics. Then they identified patterns of neurons activated when mice created a negative memory or a positive one.
A negative memory formed when mice received a mild electric shock to their feet; a positive one was formed when the mice, all male, were allowed to spend time with female mice.
Later, mice that had been shocked were put in the company of females, a positive experience, while scientists used the light to activate the memory of the shock. As a result, the negative memory became less negative: The mice became less fearful in the place where they had been conditioned to remember the shock.
The mice that originally spent time with the females later received mild electric shocks while scientists activated the neurons associated with this positive memory. The memory became less enticing, the scientists concluded: The mice froze more and sniffed less, standard measures of fear and reward in rodents.
The study's senior author, Susumu Tonegawa, a professor of biology and neuroscience at M.I.T., said the findings provided a neurological basis for psychotherapy in which patients are encouraged to unearth a good memory to reduce the feelings of a bad memory they have or stress they have had.
Roger L. Redondo, a postdoctoral student and one of the study's lead authors, said the experiments showed it was possible to alter the emotional perception of a memory without any drugs and without the mice being brought back to the area where the memory occurred.
The scientists also discovered important differences in the way neurons work in two important brain areas, the hippocampus and the amygdala. The hippocampus is involved in forming new memories and encoding factual details like where, what and when. The amygdala helps link emotions to memory.
The experiments found that neurons in the hippocampus can be changed to make a bad memory less negative, and vice versa. But neurons in the amygdala did not change, leading scientists to conclude that those neurons are prewired to reflect positive or negative emotions.
That's absolutely new, said Richard Morris, a neuroscientist at the University of Edinburgh who was not involved in the research. He said it made sense that the amygdala would have specialized neurons, because it connects to several brain areas involved in taking action.
The brain must understand quickly if an experience is, say, fearful or rewarding, so it can coordinate its response, he said.
Susan Sangha, an assistant professor of psychological sciences at Purdue University who has studied neurons in the amygdala, said an important question was â€œwhat is special about these neurons. Her research has suggested that besides reward and fear, some neurons transmit feelings of safety, and some seem to fire with any emotion.
Joshua P. Johansen, a neuroscientist at the Riken Brain Science Institute in Japan who was not involved in the research, said the findings provide clues as to how we go about tackling things like anxiety disorder.
He cautioned that the research was in its infancy and that it involved normal behaviors, not disorders. But, Dr. Johansen said, if we can figure out how to associate bad experiences with neutral or pleasurable experiences, it could guide development of drugs, gene therapy or other treatments for mental illness.
Current optogenetics techniques are not appropriate for people because they involve inserting fiber optic wires and injecting a virus containing a protein into the brain.
But the researchers said noninvasive techniques were already being explored. It's not something we can do next week or next year, but people are now developing a variety of methods, Dr. Tonegawa said. Technology develops so fast these days, so I'm quite optimistic.
[Note: Gee, I guess this means that they could also go in and find all kinds of memories or other brain functions, then turn them off or change them too. Pretty tricky, eh? Will surely get tons of funding now from all the Big Brain foundations, including Obama's [http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/checkpoint/wp/2014/08/27/new-obama-plan-calls-for-implanted-computer-chips-to-help-u-s-troops-heal/]. See also in New York Times, at:
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/08/28/science/scientists-switch-bad-memories-for-good-ones-in-mice.html?_r=0. -- The article first appeared here - DNI]